- 1 Husqvarna vs John Deere Lawn Mowers: A Comparative Review
- 1.1 Husqvarna YTA24V48 24V Fast Continuously Variable Transmission Pedal Tractor Mower, 48"/Twin
- 1.2 Lawn-Boy 17732 21-Inch 6.5 Gross Torque Kohler XTX OHV, 3-in-1 Discharge Rear Wheel Drive Self Propelled Lawn Mower
- 1.3 Husqvarna
- 1.4 John Deere
Husqvarna vs John Deere Lawn Mowers: A Comparative Review
Are you looking for a powerful lawn tractor to make mowing your big lawn a piece of cake? Then, here are two amazingly tough, easy-to-use and powerful machines to choose from.
Both Husqvarna and John Deere are big brands, manufacturing some of the best tractor lawn mowers in the world.
For this review, we have chosen Husqvarna YTA24V48 24V Fast CVT Pedal Tractor Mower (48-inch/twin) and John DeereE160 48 inch24 HP V-Twin ELS Gas Hydrostatic Lawn Tractor as their respective best. Both these tractors are strapped with 24-HPtwin-cylinder engines, custom-made for enhanced performance. They both have a 48-inch cutting deck for optimal grass coverage.
Before we move on to why these lawn tractor models are the best in their class and why one or the other would be better suited for you, let us first take a look at the two brands.
Husqvarna YTA24V48 24V Fast Continuously Variable Transmission Pedal Tractor Mower, 48"/Twin
- FAST auto transmission for a maintenance free operation
- Features choke less start, charge port and electric clutch
- Air Induction mowing technology improves airflow within the deck, ensuring a consistent cut every time
- Convenient fender mounted deck lever is spring assisted for easy operation
- 3 year limited, 5 year frame/chassis and front axle, 10 year cutting deck consumer warranty
Lawn-Boy 17732 21-Inch 6.5 Gross Torque Kohler XTX OHV, 3-in-1 Discharge Rear Wheel Drive Self Propelled Lawn Mower
- Rear Wheel Drive System provides a better traction and control on hilly terrain
- 2-Point Height-of-Cut System allows you to quickly adjust cutting heights from one side of the mower. Height of Cut- 6 Position 1.25 - 3.75 inches. Cutting Width- 21 inch
- 3 year Tru-Start Commitment - starts with 1 or 2 pulls or Lawn-Boy will fix it for free
- Kohler 149cc/ 6.5 ft.-lbs. Gross Torque/ OHV Engine
- CARB Compliant for the state of California
The Husqvarna Group, a Swedish manufacturer of outdoor power products,like chainsaws, trimmers, brush-cutters, cultivators, garden tractors, mowers, and sewing machines, started in 1689 as a rifle company. It was towards the end of the 19th century that it forayed into other machinery, like sewing machines, cast iron kitchen equipment, and bicycles. With the turn of the century, it graduated to motor-run machines, like motorcycles, lawn tractors, chainsaws, and power-cutters.
In 1918, Husqvarna acquired Norrahammars Bruk and expanded its product range to heating boilers and lawn mowers. But it was not before 1947 that the company brought out its first engine-powered lawn mower. In 1995,the company launched the world’s first solar powered robotic lawn mower. But, their sales did not pick up until 2010.
Headquartered in Stockholm, the Husqvarna Group also produces consumer watering products, cutting equipment and diamond tools for the construction and stone industries. The Group also sponsors the Swedish ice hockey club HV71 and is also involved in several local community events as well as projects across the world.
Currently, the group owns several brands, including Husqvarna, Gardena, McCulloch, PoulanPro, WeedEater, Flymo, Jonsered, Klippo, Diamant Boart, RedMax, and HTC.
Husqvarna YTA24V48 24V Fast CVT Pedal Tractor Mower is a powerful riding mower, driven by 24 HP, twin-cylinder, fast continuously variable transmission engine. This gas-powered lawn tractor works smoothly, needs far less maintenance and performs a lot better with much less energy loss, unlike hydrostatic transmissions.
Some of it unique features are:
- Fast CVT transmission for maintenance-free operation
- Chokeless start, charge port and electric clutch
- Air Induction mowing technology that enhances airflow within the deck, ensuring consistent cut each time
- 48-inch cutting width
- 24 HP, twin cylinder engine
- Electric blade engagement
- 24-volt lawn mower battery
- Convenient spring-assisted fender-mounted deck lever for easy operation
- 4 anti-scalp wheels
- 16-inch turning radius
- Easy pedal-operated driving
- Comfortable work station, with vinyl seats
- 3-year limited, 5 year frame/chassis and front axle, 10 year cutting deck consumer warranty
- Year-Round Use
Priced at $2,463.42, this gas-powered tractor weighs approximately 475 lbs, which is among the lighter ones in its class. Equipped with a 48-inch, reinforced 13-gauge steel deck, the Husqvarna YTA24V48 tractor offers premium performance with quality results. Featuring a pedal-controlled,fast auto transmission, it requires much less power to drive and provides more power for cutting grass.
John Deere of the Deere & Company is a well-known American household name, famous for manufacturing construction, agricultural, and forestry machinery, apart from diesel engines and drive trains used in heavy equipment. The company also makes garden and lawn care equipment like riding lawn mowers.
Its founder John Deere started his company in 1837 as a village repairman, working out of a humble 1,378sqft shop in Grand Detour. Soon, he started making larger tools like pitchforks and shovels for his customers. His self-scouring steel plow that he culled out of a Scottish steel saw blade gained much traction among the village folk.
From there to being ranked 102nd in America’s Fortune 500 list in 2018 was John Deere’s story of perseverance and entrepreneurial endeavors. Through thick and thin, the company stayed true to its brand slogan of “Nothing Runs Like a Deere” by creating some of the best lawn tractors, among other heavy-duty machinery, in the US.
John Deere has established manufacturing units all over the world in collaboration with several large heavy machinery makers in those respective countries.
John Deere’s E160 48-inchis one of most classy yet powerful machines in its class. This model belongs to John Deere’s ELS or extended life series, which makes the lawn tractor’s engine both hardy and durable.
Its identifying features are:
- 48-inch-wide deck, equipped with three blades, effortlessly lifts grass,providing a superior cut and smooth underside to prevent grass buildup
- 24 HP twin-cylinder ELS engine
- Advanced filtration system for better performance &longer engine life
- Hydrostatic transmission
- 300 cold crank amps battery
- John Deere EZ change 30-second oil change system
- Cruise control to set your own pace with speeds up to 5. 5 mph.
- Ready Start starting system for choke-free, car-like starts
The E160 48’s adjustable high back seat, with lumbar support, wide and comfortable operator station, and smooth steering made for easy operation. Besides, I felt its side-by-side, forward and reverse, 2-pedal foot controls were easy to handle and the electric blade engagement quite simple to use.
Priced at $2449, the product also comes with a wash port to help clean the underside of the deck. This model is also available both in offline and on online stores.
A comparative review
1. Cutting Deck Width
Both Husqvarna YTA24V48 24V Fast CVT Pedal Tractor and John DeereE160 48” 24 HP ELS Lawn Tractor come equipped with a 48-inch cutting deck, good enough for ½ to 2-acre lawns.
The Husqvarna’s deck is made from 13-gauge steel, designed to draw the air from the top and bottom of the deck to efficiently improve the grass lift and deliver a superior cut (Air Induction Mowing Technology). It also comes equipped with a convenient, spring-assisted, fender-mounted lever for easy operation. Its cutting deck has a 10-year consumer warranty.
On the other hand, the John Deere model comes with a stamped deck with a deep design, with three blades, to lift grass for a clean cut and a smooth underside to prevent grass buildup. The model comes with a wash port to clean the underside of the deck after use. The redesigned deck lift lever raises and lowers the deck easily.
In spite of its superior technology, John Deere falls a bit short of Husqvarna’s performance.
But, if I were to give my lawn a very lean cut (very short grass), I’d stay away from the Husqvarna model, as its lowest height settings seems to almost shred the lawn, negating the intended benefits of anti-scalping wheels intended to prevent turf damage when mowing over uneven ground.
2. Number of Cutting Blades
The Husqvarna YTA24V48 has a triple-blade cutting deck with an electric blade engagement system, same as the John DeereE160. Generally, all riding mowers with decks of 48-inch width and higher come with three blades.With the Husqvarna model, you get accessories like trailer, brushes, snow blade, snow throwers, graders, spreaders, detachers, aerators, brooms, rollers,mulching kit, and multiple collection bins, while with the John Deere model you get baggers, carts, aerators, spreaders, front blade, mulch kit and snow blowers. This means both are can be used all year round. An added advantage I found with the Husqvarna model is that its blades are connected to a safety switch that is powered by Reverse Operation System (ROS) technology to automatically stop the blades from rotating when backing up.
3. Speed Adjustability
While both the models have cruise control facility for a smooth and stable ride and are both good for all types of terrain, including flat ground with obstacles, hilly and steep,the Husqvarna model features a hi-speed, automatic transmission for superior transport speeds and smooth, pedal-operated, variable forward and reverse speeds. Its maximum reverse speed is 2.9 mph, only a tad bit less than John Deere’s 3.2 mph, which runs on hydrostatic transmission. Husqvarna’s automatic transmission kills the deal with its superior speed, smooth ride and efficient cut.
The Husqvarna model does not come with attached mulching blades, but can mulch perfectly well with the BioClip kit attached. It also side-discharges and collects clippings pretty well. Similarly, the John Deere model too requires a mulching kit to be attached and does mulch perfectly well. But, the former did seem to fair better in the mulching test.
Both models are gas-powered with a 24-horse power output. But, owing to the fact that the Husqvarna model is equipped with fast CVT transmission, it requires much less power to drive and can channel more to cut, unlike the John Deere model that runs on hydrostatic transmission that requires more fuel to run its hydraulic pumps.
When it comes to stability, I would say the John Deere E160 has a slight edge over the Husqvarna YTA24V48, especially during ascent. If the slope is too steep, the Husqvarna model chokes up and stops, whereas the John Deere model seemed to glide smoothly over the slope.
Husqvarna’s step-through, ergonomically built body with adjustable, high back support and vinyl seat offers adequate comfort – just like slipping into the driver’s seat of a luxury sedan. Its automatic-choke starting mechanism makes sitting down, firing it up and dismounting quite comfortable too. It also has a handy cup holder and armrest.The John Deere model has an operator station’s that is wide and comfortable, thanks to an ergonomic redesign of the whole lawn tractor. E160’s adjustable high back seat, with lumbar support, is also quite comfortable during ascent. Talking about overall comfort though, I’d say Husqvarna won in this contest, making it a luxury model among lawn tractors. An added advantage: A pressure-sensitive safety switch underneath the seat of the Husqvarna YTA24V48killedthe engine and cutting deck the moment every time I got off the saddle.
8. Height Cutting Adjustments
The Husqvarna YTA24V48’s spring-assisted, convenient fender-mounted deck lever makes for easily adjustable cutting heights. The redesigned John Deere E160’s deck lift lever also raises and lowers the deck easily, with height selections ranging from 1 inch to 4 inches, quite similar to that of the former. Personally, the adjustments felt much smoother in case of the Husqvarna model.
9. Fuel Tank Size
The YTA24V48 has a transparent fuel indicator, making for easy fuel checks while in use. You also don’t need to open the engine hood to refuel.The best part is that its tank holds up to 3 gallons of gasoline, whereas the John Deere E160’s tank can only hold up to 2.4 gallons, giving you less mowing hours.
10. Reverse Mowing
Both are adequately suited for reverse mowing, with John Deere’s reverse mowing speed being slightly ahead of the Husqvarna model at 3.2 mph. The Husqvarna offers a maximum reverse mowing speed of 2.9 mph. This tiny difference in speed may not really affect your mowing that much.
11. Overall value
The Husqvarna YTA24V48’s fast continuously variable transmission makes it slightly costlier than the John Deere E160, but it is also what makes it more cost-effective. It helps this model make up on the initial cost by saving on maintenance and fuel costs.
Both these models are adequately suitable for all kinds of terrain, for lawns covering up to 2 acres of land. They are both grand and 24 HP gas-powered, toughly built machines. They are both quite comfortable and stable too. It is quite safe to say that they can both stand the test of time.
However, the John Deere’s engine is one of its ELS variant, possibly making it more durable than the Husqvarna’s YTA24V48.
But Husqvarna’s fast continuously variable transmission and chokeless start does give it an edge in performance over John Deere’s hydrostatic transmission. Unless you are too finicky about your mowing your grass extra short or you live in an area which is too steep, the Husqvarna seems to be a clear overall winner in this contest.
Don’t worry about the slight difference in price. The Husqvarna makes up adequately for it all through the years you put it to use. It is easy to maintain and easy on the pocket too, as it makes optimal utilization of your fuel, leaving out little scope for fuel loss on riding your mower, which may be the case if your lawn tractor runs on hydrostatic transmission.