Toro vs Cub Cadet: Which Lawn Mower is the Best?

Are you on the lookout for a powerful ride behind lawn mower that makes the task of maintaining your lawn, easier for you? If that is your requirement, this is going to be an interesting piece of reading for you.

Picked out after intensive research and comparisons with each other, the Cub Cadet and Toro variants have emerged as clear winners in our selection process. Both brands are a reliable and promising deal to grab and as per our estimates, probably the best in line in riding lawn mowers.

For our comparison today, we have selected XT1 Enduro Series LT 46 in. 22-HP V-Twin KOHLER Hydrostatic Gas Front-Engine Riding Mower from Cub Cadet and Time Cutter SS4225 42 in. 22.5 HP V-Twin Gas Dual Hydrostatic Zero Turn Riding Mower with Smart Speed from Toro. Both the engines are built with twin cylinder systems, designed for optimal performance and operation. They provide excellent grass coverage for desirable operation.

 

Let us dive seep into the reason why I selected these brands, which will enlighten you about the brand itself and also throw some light upon the purpose of my selection.

Toro vs Cub Cadet

Cub Cadet 21 in. 159cc 3-in-1 High Rear Wheel Gas Walk-Behind Push Mower

$317.63  out of stock
8 new from $317.63
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of February 22, 2020 4:55 pm

Features

BindingElectronics
BrandCUB CADET
EAN0043033578580
EAN ListEAN List Element: 0043033578580
Item DimensionsHeight: 42; Width: 21
ModelSC100HW
MPNSC100HW
Package Quantity1
Part NumberSC100HW
Product GroupLawn & Patio
Product Type NameOUTDOOR_LIVING
TitleCub Cadet 21 in. 159cc 3-in-1 High Rear Wheel Gas Walk-Behind Push Mower
UPC043033578580
UPC ListUPC List Element: 043033578580

Toro 22 in. Kohler High Wheel Variable Speed Self-Propelled Gas Lawn Mower

$383.29  in stock
9 new from $383.29
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of February 22, 2020 4:55 pm

Features

  • Toro Recycler 22 in. High and Front Wheel Drive Variable Speed Self-Propelled Gas Lawn Mower with Kohler Engine

Cub Cadet

Born on American soil, the brand is known to produce a whole line of outdoor power equipment and utility vehicles for their customers. Founded in the year 1961, the brand is popular for its fleet of zero turn riders, lawn and garden tractors, gasoline powered handheld products, snow thrower and more. The products of the brand are manufactured and built by MTD Products Inc. which is based in Cleveland, Ohio.

Incredibly easy to operate and use for mowing your huge lawn, this powerful machine is perfect for you if you do not want to push a heavy gas powered lawn mower across the ground. I had been studying this Cub Cadet lawn mower and I couldn’t come to point out one flaw with its features or else, find something missing either.

Take a look at some of the remarkable features of this particular variant, which made me choose it for the comparison.

  • Typical optimised steering system which helps in responding very smartly to operation.
  • An be used under all weather conditions since it is fitted with two LED headlights.
  • Innovative and ergonomic back seat for superior elevated support.
  • Requires only minimal assembly for quick operation and manoeuvrability.
  • Superior resistance to wear and tear, thanks to an E coat corrosion defence system.

Priced at $1799, the product weighs under 600 lb, which is among the lighter versions of the product. Expect a powerful and satisfactory performance from this mammoth mulcher, with a wide cutting width of 46 inch. There are many other specifications of the product, which are perfect to keep you hooked to this feasible product.

 

Toro

This American manufacturer is known for its quality turf maintenance product range, and several other utility products, which makes every day life better for its customers. The company was founded in the year 1914 and is known to build engines for The Bull Tractor Company and various other equipment for landscape maintenance and irrigation systems.

Deciding which option might be right for you, can be a tricky job to do. I had been going through the specifications of the Toro lawn mower, which offers multiple capabilities, making me select it for this comparison.

Given the cost involved in this ride behind lawn mower, I can understand why it might be difficult to decide if you want to buy this or not. However, there are some really incredible features of this zero turn mower, which I would like to share with you here.

  • The mower is built with a powerful V twin engine, featuring a double barrel carburetor for increased power.
  • Variable control capability for dependable performance powered by dual hydrostatic transmissions.
  • Perfect for mowing around obstacles, with a clear zero turn radius.
  • Feasible 42 inch cutting width for ease of use and better performance.
  • Smart speed option for convenience and customization.

This variant is priced at $2699 and is powered by a 22.5 HP commercial V twin 708 cc engine, which is unique in many ways. This product is something worth going over at least once, before you decide the ultimate lawn mower for your back yard.

 

Comparing the two giants for the best ride behind the back lawn mower!

Let us compare the two models, based on some vital features, which I believe to be pertinent when making the decision of the best lawn mower for your garden. I would personally consider these elements of a product when purchasing a lawn mower for my garden.

Cutting Deck Width

You might want to consider checking the cutting deck width of the mower of your choice before choosing one, since it will decide how many round trips you are going to make around in your lawn to get the job done. The Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series LT 46 in. 22-HP V-Twin KOHLER Hydrostatic Gas Front-Engine Riding Mower offers a cutting width of 46 inches with 2 blades, built with 12 gauge steel material.

One the other hand, the TimeCutter SS4225 42 in. 22.5 HP V-Twin Gas Dual Hydrostatic Zero Turn Riding Mower with Smart Speed offers a 42 inch bladed mowing system, which is built under a 4 inch deep top discharge deck. This helps you get to the tight spots, which might appear difficult to manoeuver at first.

In spite of the ease of use and flexible manoeuvrability, the Toro falls short in performance here. You might want to go for the Cub Cadet here since it is definitely going to get the job done for you faster and in less time. If I were to choose a lawn mower for my lawn, I would pick the Cub Cadet for its wider cutting deck width.

Number of Cutting Blades

The TimeCutter SS4225 42 in. 22.5 HP V-Twin Gas Dual Hydrostatic Zero Turn Riding Mower with Smart Speed and the Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series LT 46 in. 22-HP V-Twin KOHLER Hydrostatic Gas Front-Engine Riding Mower are both endowed with 2 blade cutting systems. For a medium sized mower such as these two, I couldn’t have asked for something more on this front. Not much of a comparison here. The Toro variant offers a 17,810 ft./min blade tip speed, which is lower than the Cub Cadet and for that I would affirm my choice for the Cub cadet variant.

Speed Adjustability

The Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series LT 46 in. 22-HP V-Twin KOHLER Hydrostatic Gas Front-Engine Riding Mower offers a maximum forward speed of 5.5 mph and a maximum reverse speed of 2.5 mph, which can be varied and adjusted as per requirement. The 22 HP mower does a splendid job with this feature since it allows you to mow your lawn perfectly with its hydrostatic transmission.

On the other hand, the TimeCutter SS4225 42 in. 22.5 HP V-Twin Gas Dual Hydrostatic Zero Turn Riding Mower with Smart Speed offers a forward speed of 7 mph and 3 mph for reverse. The hydrostatic transmission type helps in gearing the mower for variable speed but if I were to pick one out of the two, I would opt for the Club Cadet because for a medium size mower, the speed variability to such extent is not really helpful, since you might come across a number of obstacles on your mowing trip.

I would pick the Cub cadet in this matter, because of its helpful manoeuvrability around obstacles and hard to reach areas.

Mulching

The Cub cadet version provide mulching capabilities, which is what I would look for, in my lawn mower. However, the Toro variant is designed for side discharge and bagging. The mulching kit is not reliable and the mower works better without the kit. For this reason, I would pick the Cub Cadet variant any day.

Horsepower

The Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series LT 46 in. 22-HP V-Twin KOHLER Hydrostatic Gas Front-Engine Riding Mower is designed with a 22 HP featuring an air cool design, and a low oil shut off, spark arrestor, full power panel and engine shut off switch.

On the other hand, the TimeCutter SS4225 42 in. 22.5 HP V-Twin Gas Dual Hydrostatic Zero Turn Riding Mower with Smart Speed is built on a 22.5 HP feature and Toro’s signature V twin engine design that is built upon most Toro equipment. On this front, you might want to pick the Toro, since it outperforms the Cub Cadet with its double barrel carburettor and V-intake for increased power.

Stability

While both the variants come with an electric start option, I am particularly inclined towards the Cub Cadet variant since it can work on hilly and steep terrain perfectly, without choking. However, the Toro version works only on flat surfaces, which pulls it back in the race.

Comfort

The Cub Cadet is designed with open high back seat that is built with an oversized base and elevated back support and Soft touch, rubberized comfort grip steering wheel provides a solid feel and controlled steering. Moreover, a unique Push button cruise control maintains a desired speed for consistent mowing. The Toro comes with a18 inch extra tall seat and specially designed integrated fenders to keep you clean and dry. The device is also low maintenance with quick drain oil hose that does not require tools. On this aspect, I would recommend choosing something that fits your comfort and since that is subjective for all of us, you need to evaluate the features that you might want in your lawn mower.

Height Cutting Adjustments

The Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series LT 46 in. 22-HP V-Twin KOHLER Hydrostatic Gas Front-Engine Riding Mower requires a minimum cutting height of only 1 inch with adjustable cutting heights while the TimeCutter SS4225 42 in. 22.5 HP V-Twin Gas Dual Hydrostatic Zero Turn Riding Mower with Smart Speed requires a minimum cutting height of 1.5 inches. I would hold the Cub Cadet a clear winner on this aspect, since it proves to be more efficient, when it comes to maintaining your lawn and mowing for optimum performance. The Cub Cadet proves to be a winner here since it can trim even low grass levels, which the Toro falls back at.

Fuel Tank Size

Both the Toro and Cub Cadet variants offer a wider running capacity with 3 gallon fuel tank size that allows you to go on without stopping for a refill.

Reverse Mowing

The smart speed control in the Toro variant offers a 3 mph speed while reversing while the Cub Cadet variant offers the same up to a maximum speed of 2.5 mph. With this slight difference in the speeds, I would not declare either of them as a winner in this respect. However, I would like to mention this versatile speed variability is definitely something that I look forward to, in a lawn mower since it gives the device added manoeuvrability and flexibility for operation.

Overall value

The unique features and the aesthetic transmission of the Cub Cadet makes it a clear winner here. It is cost effective and offers much more than the Toro lawn mower, which is not only costly for what it offers but also falls behind on many features.

Our take

The Cub Cadet power packed equipment is not only cost effective but delivers excellent performance with the smoothest transmission which does not require shifting gears. The impressive engine and cutting deck cuts the grass with precision that is unbeatable. For working on hilly and steep terrain, its rear drive wheels offer excellent traction and handling capability. The 16” turning radius of the mower allows you to reach tough corners. The cutting deck can be lowered and raised easily with a fender mounted lever and the push button cruise control allows easy focus on steering, without the need to manage the speed.

For an uneven terrain, you couldn’t pick something better than this Cub Cadet variant. It is the most affordable pick in the market right now!